Being a Zelda Loremaster

This post is going to be similar to my write up on the review of the storyline and the consistency post. It’s basically an, “if I could remake the Zelda series in my own image,” type of post. I have a list of about 10 things that I would go back in time and change, if I could. Most of it isn’t personal - things like telling Archimedes to use the radius instead of the diameter when calculating π or telling Benjamin Franklin that it’s the negative charges that move in an electrical circuit, not the positive charges. As it pertains to Zelda, I wouldn’t want to change too much about it - I would want the games to be mostly as they already are with only slight tweaks and changes to the in-game text and manuals (other changes to reduce tedium would be nice, but we’re focusing on just story and lore for now).


It would be nice to have the Lore of Zelda be as deep as Tolkien’s, where it’s easy to tell that they had some of the history worked out beforehand instead of just making it up as they go, and when a new group of writers comes in they don’t throw out what was written before (something that happens in comic books far too often). Along with that would come some geographical consistency, and landmarks that wouldn’t be constantly moving around.

I would love the idea of having all of this pre-planned out years in advance, and having each game serve as revealing one small chapter of the entire over-arching tale of Hyrule, kinda like how the game show Classic Concentration revealed an entire picture once all of the cards were removed. And as part of that, it might not seem like each game is connected entirely or seems to have wildly different geography until a future game explains exactly what happened that serves as a bridge between games, and at some point the entire story would suddenly come into focus, making Miyamoto/Aonuma seem like geniuses (I suppose Breath of the Wild or its sequel would be a perfect story to do so).


So, if I could magically transport myself back to 1980’s Kyoto, Japan (speaking perfect Japanese, of course) and serve as a special advisor to Shigeru Miyamoto and whatever team was working on the Zelda games, here’s what I would do.

The first thing is to inform Mr. Miyamoto that while it might not seem like it now, the lore of the series is going to be scrutinized so it would behoove him to get some of the facts straight before writing up the backstory in the first game’s manual. Realizing that he cares far more about the world he’s creating than the reason behind why someone would want to play there, I would offer to serve as Loremaster of the series, and mostly work with advanced knowledge of the games to make small adjustments to what they (the designers) create. This advanced knowledge would come in handy for things like coming up with explanations about small inconsistencies such as the sudden disappearance of Gorons in the downfall timeline (I could write that the destruction forced them all to Labrynna/Holodrum), or why there were no towns/castles in the first game’s map (the actual answer being technical limitations but it’s easy enough to have a story-based reason as well).

As it stands now, the symbology throughout the games is frustrating when there could be some really great lore that shows the evolution of the symbols with their associated peoples/groups. For example, the 3 symbols for the 3 time songs from Oracle of Ages somehow became associated with the Triforces in Wind Waker and it has been that way ever since. The fact that they were used in Skyward Sword (first in chronology, mind you) means that it’s all kinds of screwed up for when/how the symbols are used. The Hylian shield showing up in Link’s Awakening HD and the Master Sword in the Oracle games is kinda the same thing - instead of the items retaining special meaning/value, it is just the “Zelda version of ‘best’ shield/sword”. The way the goddess symbol combines with the bird and Triforce can be kinda cool if they did it consistently/correctly. Symbology done correctly would be really interesting and meaningful.


I like the idea of a cyclical tale - even the Matrix did it (poorly, admittedly), and that each incarnation is a bit of a different tale. What I would really like is if they planned out a major release with a new incarnation of Link/Zelda who saves Hyrule, then that particular Link does 2 or 3 gaiden games that slightly reference the first one - sorta like how they retroactively made the GBC games all sequels to Link to the Past. In fact, between the handhelds and the consoles, that could work out pretty well. Release a 3D console game (like Ocarina of Time or Wind Waker) that deal with Hyrule/Ganon/Triforce and then have two or three 2D handheld games (like Minish Cap or Phantom Hourglass) that have the followup side-story of that particular incarnation of Link/Zelda that doesn’t involve Ganon or the Triforce. I realize that consoles and handhelds don’t line up as well as they need to be for this to happen, but it’s a nice thought.


The music is somewhat consistent - like how Zora’s domain and Goron City have always had similar music, and Zelda’s theme is always on point. The main Hyrule overworld theme has been used haphazardly - how it was absent in Ocarina of Time but present in Majora’s Mask, etc. If it was the overworld theme only when the adventure was in Hyrule it would be more consistent. As with the various symbols, name places, etc., there should be thought into why these musical choices were made and not just shameless fanservice callbacks.

While I appreciated the BotW map showing “regions” that were named after past Zelda places/people, it doesn’t really make sense in the timeline, unless it’s intended for the merging of the three timelines to happen (TBD). Otherwise it’s just fanservicey callbacks.


Basically, all it would have taken is a little forethought - which is the difference between how the MCU succeeded (at least through Endgame) and Star Wars shat the bed recently. Like even Lucas had a plan when he “wedgied out” the capital ships in episodes 2 and 3 of Star Wars to seem like a progression from those to the Star Destroyers of the OT. Precursors of TIE fighters and X-Wings were present and their evolution is easy to deduce, whereas the Disney sequels are just a mess with no internal logic or consistency. Meanwhile, the MCU treated each movie almost like it’s one episode of a series, and despite having different directors/producers on each movie, they all remain consistent with each other to a high degree. We could think of individual games as chapters in the history of Hyrule and weave a grand tapestry of lore.

Grab-bag Post #1

This post is going to be a random collection of easily digestible opinions and ideas that might not be fully formed, but most contains thoughts that don't have enough substance to warrant its own post. 

"Impossible Mode"

I'm not a fan of games that include some kind of extremely difficult mode. Two examples that jump to mind are Hollow Knight's steel soul mode, and Shovel Knight's trophy of finishing the game without falling into a hole. I know, I know, I should just "git gud." But the thing that bugs me is that it's like they don't realize I have a backlog of games a mile long. I like 100%-ing games, and when I see those kinds of modes/trophies I just lose interest because in order to do it I would have to dedicate all of my gaming time to this one game for months on end and it just doesn't seem worth it. Maybe if I was a kid who only had 3 games or was somehow stranded on an island with only 1 game to play, then sure.

"Console Generations"

I've remarked that assigning consoles to "generations" post-hoc is somewhat arbitrary, just like how we label different eras of comic books (Golden Age, Silver Age, etc.). But I kinda do like the idea for organizational purposes. But what would be really nice is if the major console manufacturers got together and had a gentlemen's agreement to only release a new console every 7 years (and all within a few months of each other) with a minor hardware revision somewhere in year 4 (like the New 3DS or X-Box One X). That would make it easier to classify generations but it would also let programmers/designers fully flesh out the capabilities of each machine and get the most out of the hardware before we move onto bigger/better. Look at how much better games like Batman: Return of the Joker looked on the NES compared to something like CluClu Land, or compare DKC and Star Fox to Super Mario World. I realize the major drawbacks are that if someone produces a flop they have to sit on it for 6 years before fixing their mistake (see Wii U to Switch lessons) and that it would have completely eliminated Sega's hardware strategy in the 90's. But it's a nice thought to have just so I can more easily label things and put them in their proper boxes. 

Star Wars Transmission Errors

One thing I've heard about culture is that it's passed on from one generation to the next, and over time some things stick while other things evolve, and still others are pruned off. But as part of that, I see a lot of parents transmit their hobbies or love of a particular thing to their kids, like sport team affiliation. I've certainly done that in the case of video games and superheroes to my kids to a certain extent. But what's interesting to me is how I was able to get Avery on board with Star Wars when he was young but Logan has very little interest. And I think I can point to the Sequel Trilogy (and Disney's acquisition of LFL in general) as the culprit. Before the dark times, I would watch the various movies regularly, but not so much once the ST came out. Avery was also young during the post PT/Clone Wars times when there were a lot of good Star Wars things coming out. I also think to a certain extent that I've not been wanting to pass it on as much, now that I know the ending sucks (similar to how I won't recommend someone start watching Game of Thrones because the ending is so awful). 

Using up all the good stuff

I feel like there needs to be years of comics to tell a coherent story and for some editing/retconning to make it good before it graduates to a movie. Comics being the visual medium that it is, it necessarily follows that one issue can't be the source plot/dialogue for a whole movie, or even an episode of a TV show. It takes several issues to tell a story arc, and not all story arcs are created equally. When you take a property like the X-Men, for example, there are decades of stories from which to draw inspiration to either create a somewhat original patchwork story (like the first movie) or major stories that were particularly well done (like how God Loves, Man Kills was adapted into X2 or Days of Future Past was adapted into, well, Days of Future Past). But it seems to me that Hollywood doesn't share these concerns with keeping the product pure and of high quality. Adapting more recent things like the Kamala Kahn Ms. Marvel seems premature because we don't have the benefit of hindsight to see if it made a lasting impact on the franchise. In addition, seeing more recent comic stories being the focal points of movies/shows feels like they’re rushing things and will soon run out of source material - just like Game of Thrones when it surpassed GRRM’s books or how The Walking Dead caught up to the comic plot. It's safer to use an animated series as test waters to see how well a particular story works before sending it to the big screen. Also, in their rush to get their newer, more woke characters which only entered the comics as early as 6 years ago, Marvel Studios is skipping past stories that sold hundreds of thousands of copies in order to adapt stories that sell just thousands of copies. 

Grab-bag Post #2

Grab-bag Post #3

Grab-bag Post #4

My Experience with Zelda Part 5

Previous Entries:

My Experience with Zelda Part 1

My Experience with Zelda Part 2

My Experience with Zelda Part 3

My Experience with Zelda Part 4


For Christmas 2017, Anne got me a Breath of the Wild blanket, featuring an image of Link shooting an ancient arrow. It was warm and soft and I soon started using it whenever I was on the couch and cold. She started calling it my "magic blanket," since whenever I laid down with it on me I fell asleep fairly quickly. 

The third entry of the Dark Horse Zelda books came out in June of 2018 - the Zelda Encyclopedia. I pre-ordered it clear back in December, but it took 6 months to finally become available. The colors and release order of these books coincidentally match the boxes of the Extended Editions of the Lord of the Rings movie sets. 



Over the summer of 2018 Anne, Aurora, Logan and I played through Four Swords Adventures using the 3 GBA SPs we have between us and the modified backlit GBA hooked up to the Wii emulating a Gamecube. This marks the game where Anne has now completed the same number of Zelda games as Avery. Logan, on the other hand, has finished them all (at least in one form or another). She finished Twilight Princess HD next and then Tri-Force Heroes. This only leaves Skyward Sword and Breath of the Wild for her to finish. 

In the fall of 2018 I finally figured out how to get Custom Firmware on my 3DS thanks to the fine people of /r/3dshacks, which allowed me to do a couple of things I've wanted for a while. First, I finally have a copy of Minish Cap on my 3DS, and second, I have digital versions of all my favorite games so I don't have to carry around a case with gamecards. So what that means is that I have all Zelda games except 5 on my 3DS (WW, FSA, TP, SS, and BotW). 

But beyond that, it has opened up a whole new avenue for some of the spin-off games that I either never could play before or had to jump through a whole bunch of hoops and/or pay a lot of money to play. It wasn't too long until I also had BS-TLoZ Map 1, BS-TLoZ Map 2, and BS-TLoZ: AST installed onto my system. I followed them up with the 4 Tingle games (which admittedly, I only did for the completionist in me): Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland, Tingle's Balloon Fight, Too Much Tingle Pack, and Tingle's Balloon Trip of Love. I also got the 3DS version of Hyrule Warriors and a Twilight Princess themed Picross game, and a GBA port of the Zelda Game & Watch game. Which is to say that with the exception of Link's Crossbow Training and the actual Zelda wristwatch, I had all of the (official) Zelda spin-off games on my 3DS. 

3DS CFW also allowed me an experience that I didn't think I would ever have. By installing the Japanese version of the original Legend of Zelda, I was able to finally yell into a microphone to kill a Pol's Voice. The original Famicom's controller 2 had a microphone instead of Start/Select buttons, and a few games integrated this feature. The manual for TLoZ mentioned that they were afraid of sound, and most people assumed it referred to the Recorder (flute), similar to how Digdogger is weakened. But since the US version of the NES didn't have a microphone, the programmers altered the monster with the weakness of being killed by arrows without updating the manual.

Around this same time, the Nintendo Switch Online launched, and came with a feature to play old NES games. I made a Japanese account so I could also download the Famicom equivalent, and was able to play Japanese versions of both Zelda 1 and 2. The only real difference in Zelda 1 was a few sound effects (the FDS had an additional sound channel available) and more accurate hints from the old man (i.e., no Engrish transrations). But Zelda 2 had several interesting changes - a few in the graphics/sound area but mostly in the leveling up system. Later I learned how to emulate the FDS on my 3DS including the startup BIOS and having to switch to the B side of a disk (and sitting through the loading wait time). 

Just after Christmas, I happened to spot Creating a Champion, the fourth Zelda book from Dark Horse, while perusing the store. I wasn't really planning on getting it, but I had some Christmas money to spend and so I got it and now have all four volumes displayed on some nicer bookshelves in our living room. 

After playing a few of the Tingle games, I decided I might as well play all of the spin-off and non-canon games, even the unholy trilogy that we normally do not speak of (*shudders*). This involved downloading two different emulators for the PC. One emulator (MESS) could play two of the games and had controller support, but wouldn't play the cut scenes, so I had a YouTube video of them pulled up and would watch them at the proper time. It supported Save States, so I could get through some of the frustrating parts without having to start whole levels over. The other emulator (TinyCDi) could play the other game using a keyboard but wouldn't do Save States and would crash every time Zelda died. But I got through them finally. 

The next big news for the Zelda world was the announcement of another spin-off game called Cadence of Hyrule. In a similar vein to Hyrule Warriors, this was a game was a coat of Zelda paint on another style of game. In this case, it was Crypt of the Necrodancer, which I had never heard of before. I got excited for it and pre-purchased it (as well as the original CotN game) but it turns out that we were supposed to be in Vegas on a family vacation when it was to be released. So I couldn't really play it upon release and it took a little while to get back into it. 

In the process of finishing the latest spin-off game (CoH), I came across another one that I hadn't played - Navi Trackers. It was a process to get it working. Because it was only released in Japan (and Korea, strangely), I could either try getting a Japanese GameCube and disc, or hard-modding my American GameCube (and still buy the disc). But I found option #3: getting Custom Firmware on my Wii U. So after doing all the work to get it working, I got everything set up and ready to play only to find out that there isn't the "hardware handshake" protocol between the Wii U and the GBA when emulating the Gamecube. So that meant option #4: getting it working on the CFW Wii (which worked, thankfully). I played a few levels with each of my family, but only in pairs (meaning, never with 3 or 4 people). Having to teach them how it works because they can't understand Japanese was kinda neat, too. 

In September of 2019, the second Link's Awakening remake was released for the Switch. It's not officially called Link's Awakening HD, but most people on the internet refer to it that way to distinguish it from the original b/w Link's Awakening and the GBC remake (DX). I was very glad to get to play one of my favorite games in glorious, gorgeous HD with the harder difficulty. And the new dungeon maker mode of play is . . . okay. I think the game should have been more like $40 instead of full price, but apparently I'm a sucker for anything Zelda. Avery and I both got a copy from GameStop on the midnight release (along with a poster). 

After seeing a copy of it at a used game store, it occurred to me that the manual inside of the plastic case for my copy of Four Sword Adventures has been missing its cover ever since I bought it. I had never seen the cover until that day and it bummed me out. Fortunately I devised a solution - use a hi-res scan PDF of the manual and the color copier at work to reproduce it. It took a few tries to get the exact dimensions and to get the front and back sides to match up exactly on a 2-sided print, but I eventually succeeded and restored the manual to its former glory. Along those same lines, I occasionally see the Gamecube Collector's disc, which has LoZ, AoL, OoT, and MM on one disk along with previews of other games. I'm tempted to get it but unwilling to pay the high price at the moment. Perhaps when the house is paid off . . . 

Then after some months of looking at one, I finally bit the bullet and purchased a 30-year-old digital watch just to play the Legend of Zelda Game Watch. I put more details in the Spin-off post, but while I'm glad to own a piece of Zelda history, the experience of playing it isn't anything to write home about. But I at least persevered through it so I could honestly claim that I have finished it. 

Anne reached the point where she only had Skyward Sword and Breath of the Wild to finish, and I decided that she should do Skyward first. I also took it as an opportunity to finally get around to playing it through a second time. While it wasn't quite as bad as I had been touting all these years, there were still many frustrations and problems that bothered me. I wrote more about this experience in its own post. Logan also decided that he wanted to complete all of the spin-off games as well, so he slogged through the CD-i games on our computer and did the rest on his 3DS. I think the only one he didn't finish is Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland. 

While I obviously have all of the games, I'm not usually one for merch. I need it to provide me with lore, backstory, or some other kind of content. After buying the four Dark Horse books, I decided to try the Mangas. I let Anne know of my plans and so I started getting them for birthdays/Christmases starting in 2019. The first ones were Twilight Princess vol.1-3 and then the version of LttP that was in Nintendo Power along with LttP/MM. I've slowly amassed all of the Legendary Editions of the Himekawa books, and am now only needing to finish the Twilight Princess books. As I'm very much an, "In for a penny, in for a pound," kind of collector, I looked into all of the older mangas/books as well. Using online resources, I found a fairly good list of publications, including various comics, mangas, guidebooks, sheet music, and novels based on the games. For now, I managed to find digital scans of almost everything, which will be enough for now. Perhaps in the future I might hunt down these elusive pieces of Zelda history. 

I did a few of projects on the computer to kill some time. The first was to complete my Musical Journey Through Hyrule edit. It was something that I started while anticipating Breath of the Wild but I got distracted once it (and the Switch) came out. The second was to make desktop wallpaper of the various Zelda game logos. It was easy enough to do the various spin-offs as well, so I did. Once I finished that, I got the idea to use Photoshop to make a somewhat realistic version of the LoZ title screen, using real textures. I had so much fun that I decided to do it for all of the main games. 

Another way I flexed my Photoshop skills was to make a Zelda poster. I had previously made one for Avengers: Infinity War that had the various MCU movie posters based off of one my brother saw online. The problem with the one he saw was that the movies were out of order and some of them were the international release posters. I recreated it in Photoshop with the correct posters and added things like the Netflix shows. After Endgame came out I made an updated one with the newer movies and took out some of the TV stuff. But I had the idea to also make a Zelda one. The problem was that unlike movie posters, the game boxes were sometimes vertically oriented (NES, and Gamecube on), sometimes horizontal (SNES, N64), and sometimes square-ish (handhelds). My solution was to make them all squarish and just expand the picture as needed. It turned out pretty well and I spent weeks going over minutia to eliminate mistakes that would only be a couple of pixels in size. We got a few misprints and were informed that they wouldn't refund anything, unfortunately, but we had enough to cover the orders from ourselves and friends/family. Later I made one for the spin-off games, but never got it printed since I'm probably the only one who would appreciate such a thing. 

During the Spring 2020 when everything went tits up because of the 'rona, we spent some of the time doing home improvement projects and I decided to make myself a lamp like one I've seen people make on Reddit. Using a piece of oak and some very precise calculations, I got the wood frame all done, then finished it with some plexiglass and rice paper, some LED light strips, and some leftover fabric to make a lamp that can change colors and is dimmable. 

While I enjoyed the 3DS version of Majora's Mask for the updated graphics and portability, there were quite a few changes they made that I wasn't too keen on, such as the Zora swimming nerf and the boss battles. Thankfully, a group of people who know how to patch such things made a patch available for those of us who have custom firmware. It fixes many of the problems that crept into the remake and makes it more like the original N64 version. 

Over the summer, the big thing I was looking forward to was the release of Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity. Truth be told, I wasn't the biggest fan of the first game, but this one looked more like Breath of the Wild so I was a little more excited. Avery picked up our copies on release day (along with a keychain). However, it happened to release right when I was in the middle of a few games so I put it off and didn't play it for a few weeks. However, I found myself rather enjoying the game, as Aonuma-san had given Koei Tecmo some direction and insight to making it feel more Zelda-like. This article articulates a lot of what I thought and felt about it. 

To complement my lamp I made, Brady found a Triforce tree topper on clearance at GameStop and sent it my way. Anne also finished Breath of the Wild just after Christmas 2020, making 19 out of 19 Zelda games completed for her. She practiced her profanity skills and learned some patience along the way, but for now she can claim to have at least completed all of the games (for now). Convincing her to do the spin-offs or 100% them . . . that's a different story.